No, not like that you degenerates, foul weather. Now that you’ve finally left your house and are out backpacking, camping, hiking etc you will need to consider foul weather or rain gear. This would be part of the planning process to begin with,  as you’ll want it to balance with your area, situation and type of trip. Things to consider are, besides the obvious weather, are the region or terrain you will be in, time of year, the length or type of trip and other gear. You don’t want to bring too little or too much.

The region you will be in is probably going to play the biggest part in your gear choice. If you are going to be in a desert then you will not need much of anything. Rain does happen in the desert and flash floods are a real hazard so you will still want to keep it in mind. In the desert since it is usually warm/hot and dry most of the time you could probably just forgo the personal protection and only worry  about your gear. If you are somewhere with a lot of rain then you will obviously want to have a more thorough suite of gear. Some places with microclimates or very unpredictable weather will require a sort of half and half approach. I do most of my trips in fairly high mountains so the weather changes quickly and somewhat unpredictably. My normal foul weather set is pretty simple, a hard-shell jacket, gore tex/waterproof boots and the standard rainfly with the tent. My backpacks are semi waterproof, they were originally waterproof 20 years ago but the coating is mostly toast by now. Most summer storms there while at times strong are usually short. So normally I would pull out my jacket and continue about my business or wait it out (depends on lightning too, don’t go tromping around when it’s likely). They are infrequent though so just those minimums are usually fine.

Time of year is obviously a big part of the weather. For example getting rained on in the desert in summer is probably welcomed by most but in winter not so much. 

The length of time you will be out is something to think about. Is it just a short excursion you could literally drag yourself back from if you had to? Or are you going to be out for weeks? For long duration trips you should expect to be needing rain gear more than once, and you will want to bring a repair kit for it. Even if it’s just some duct tape it will make a difference. A rip or puncture early on can essentially ruin or even end a trip depending on just how much rain you get. “Controversial” opinion; if it’s a simple day hike near your house don’t bother with anything. I hear people say that you need to leave with all sorts of stuff with you and tut tut anyone who doesn’t. If toddlers are on the trail I’m pretty sure you’re fine. Plus most local trails have plenty of traffic with other hikers who can help you out if you somehow are stuck. For those that wander off trails and get lost (even though it’s virtually in sight of town), well that’s just Darwinism. If it starts to rain just hustle back to the car. Now if you are doing a day hike starting from a backcountry camp then yes take your gear. 
Other gear interactions are not so much a category as just a general thought process. If you are taking a hard-shell jacket already then a soft shell is redundant. Or if you already have a lot of weight then you might need to cut out some items. One anecdote, when I worked at a dealership they had these old school yellow rain coats for us when it rained. The yellow type that comes down to your calves. First time we got a storm we all ran and got them. Well with the length of the coats the water would run down and just drench our lower legs and feet. Then on top of that, the rubber material would make us steamy underneath to the point we were wetter wearing those things than if we hadn’t. So we would have needed gaiters or pants for those jackets to work as well as some more venting. Just make sure things work together.

No Cotton: As the saying goes, “cotton kills” Make sure you have as little cotton on you as possible. In the old days this meant wool but nowadays there are plenty of synthetic materials available that are usually more comfortable and fast drying. Although merino wool seems to be the new hotness. Cotton takes a long time to dry when it gets wet which just leaves you open to hypothermia. 

Poncho (tarp): the good old multiuse poncho. If you want to go super minimalist you could do the retro method of just taking a poncho and use that as your personal rain protection and your tent/sleeping rain protection. And it will cover your backpack as you wear it too. It saves on the amount of gear you carry but you can only use it for one purpose at a time. So if you have it over your tent/sleeping bag well it’s going to have to stay there until it stops raining. Plus you can’t use it to layer up for added warmth.

Rain Jacket/Coat/Hard-shell: This is the most common piece people have and think of. Modern parlance often calls them “hard-shell” jackets but that does imply it’s a modern breathable waterproof jacket and not the old school rubberized type. These are essentially a beefed up windbreaker in most cases, with no lining. These pack down nice and small so it’s easy to just have one in a pants pocket or outer ruck pouch for quick access. These type of jackets work well with the layering principle, add one over the top of a fleece and it bumps the warmth up considerably.

Soft Shells: These are the fancy jackets that are pretty popular with most everyone these days. They offer some water resistance (not proof) and good breathability. The downside is the lack of waterproof-ness of these. So water will get through. They’re really only meant for drizzles or if you’re doing a lot of physical activity where you need breathability more than water repellency. Personally I like them but just can’t find a use for them. They are heavier than a fleece and hard-shell combo and not as waterproof, so if it starts to do more than a heavy mist you will need an additional layer anyways.

Pack covers or waterproof liners/bags: These are handy. Which you choose will depend on your scenario. If it’s just heavy rain you’re worried about then the cover will be the best choice in my opinion. If you are going to be fording rivers then the liners/bags inside the pack will be better. 

Rainfly: I have heard of people not taking their rainfly with them on trips but I think it’s much better to have something. Even when there is no rain you can still have mist or dew that falls on you. And you don’t want to deal with a wet night. I usually set it up but if it’s hot just leave the fly doors open or if it’s really hot then undo one side and pull it back. That way if it does start to rain I can just grab it and pull it back over quickly.

Gore-Tex or waterproof boots: These are a must in my mind. You can always just treat some boots as well with a spray. It’s nice not to have to worry about them getting wet or having wet socks in general.

Rain pants/gaiters: I’ve never used these so don’t have much to say about them. They are also definitely in the optional category. I have seen some interesting use of boots and gaiters being used like mini waders by a guy once which was pretty slick. He had waterproof gaiters cinched tight over Gore-Tex boots so he could just wade through the streams/creeks without having to find rocks or logs to cross. Granted this is only useful for water less than knee high but if you have a lot of shallow water to cross it might be worth considering. I have had rain pants in the past but never got any use out of them. They are usually a hassle to put on, often requiring you to remove your boots, and my regular pants never manage to get all that wet most of the time anyways. Maybe if it’s REALLY wet in your area they would be handy. Also I was always afraid I would rip them if I tried to sit on a rock. In this case I think soft shell pants might actually be pretty useful and they are typically pretty durable and breathable. But they are also pretty pricey. 

Trash Bag: Yep, a trash bag, takes up almost no space or weight but you can pull it out and either cover yourself like a poncho by making a hole in the bottom or cover your backpack. If you use the heavier duty black garden ones you can get more than one use out of it. plus you can use it for a solar still or other emergency uses.

My go to set up, from base layer to top layer then gear;
– Maybe some kind of synthetic t-shirt and underwear (not always but it is helpful)
– Nylon or similar pants (found some nice ones at Costco for maybe $15, you really don’t need high end stuff a lot of the time) or most often I find myself wearing a pair of Vertx poly-cotton one so I can have pockets to shove stuff in.
–  A nylon or synthetic long sleeve button up, preferably on the thinner side. Provides sun and bug protection but I’m able to roll the sleeves up and down to adjust my temperature.
– My old Merrell Gore-Tex boots 
– A decent fleece jacket, the thicker the better
– A hard-shell (Marmot or Mountain Hardware have my seal of approval)
That’s really about it for clothes. If it gets colder than where those items help I’ll add on gloves and a beanie or balaclava. That’s usually enough into the 40’s. For colder temps a down vest is a good go to addition to beef up the layers without having to pack a ton of stuff. If it’s going to be constantly cold or low 40s and below then some kind of parka should probably replace the hard-shell jacket. For gear I usually just stick with the rainfly that comes with the tent and that’s it. If it’s raining hard enough that it could soak through my backpack then I’ll either move into the trees or just hunker down until it lets up. Or take out my trash bag and cover the top of my pack. I have taken a small tarp before but got no use out of it. Trying to keep my gear/weight to a minimum.

Redbeard Tactical (yeah those guys again) had a post where he (they?) used just a wind breaker and low loft jacket under a DWR treated field shirt. It’s a very light weight option and has gotten me thinking. I will probably try that out next year and see how I like it.


1 Comment

  1. John M. says:

    A few thoughts on rain:
    1. It’s not just that cotton takes a long time to dry, it’s that cotton’s insulation value goes negative when it gets wet. You are better off taking it off than leaving it on when it’s wet. That’s not true for wool or (some? all?) synthetics. And not incidentally, if you are wearing wet cotton and you are cold, get it off you. It’s not helping.
    2. If chill is a risk, you want to have a way to light a fire and the know-how to do so when wood is wet. Carrying your own tinder goes a long way, too (e.g. Vaseline-soaked cotton balls).
    3. If it’s warm out, consider stripping to your shorts and using your rain protection on your pack. It keeps your clothes dry.


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s